A carbon tax is better than green subsidies.

Before you read

Where do you stand on this motion?

Read both casesAbout 4 minutes · reviewed 10 November 2026

How it works

Warm, not heated.

We set out the strongest case on each side of a contested question, so that readers can disagree well.

1VoteSay where you stand before you read: agree, unsure, or disagree.
2Read both casesThe case for and the case against, at equal length, with the facts both sides accept.
3Vote againSee whether your view moved, and how other readers' views shifted.

One contested question each morning, with both cases. Unsubscribe at any time.

2A carbon tax is better than green subsidies.Evidence and values · 10 Nov 2026Evidence and values10 Nov 2026
1The UK should build new nuclear power stations at scale.Evidence and values · 10 Nov 2026Evidence and values10 Nov 2026

3Farmland should be rewilded even at the cost of food production.Evidence and values · 10 Nov 2026Evidence and values10 Nov 2026

5AI companies should pay creators for training data.Evidence and values · 10 Nov 2026Evidence and values10 Nov 2026
4Under-16s should be banned from social media.Evidence and values · 10 Nov 2026Evidence and values10 Nov 2026

Columns: motion number, motion, what the disagreement is about, and date last reviewed.